UK Premium Index live · refreshed with each ABI & Confused.com release Independent · Editorial · Information only — disclosures in footer
Compare Quotes

How to compare car insurance quotes in the UK

Comparing is the single biggest lever on what you pay, but only if you compare like for like. This guide covers what to have ready, which cover to compare, when to buy and how to tell whether a quote is fair. We don't offer quotes ourselves and we don't earn from any link on this page, so there is nothing here to sell you.

Typical UK car insurance costs

Independent research from our UK cost index — sourced from ABI and Confused.com published data.

Use more than one comparison site

The four big UK comparison sites are Compare the Market, MoneySuperMarket, Go.Compare and Confused.com. Each works with a different panel of insurers and brokers, and none of them covers the whole market, so the cheapest quote on one site is often missing from another.

  • Run the same details through at least two sites. It takes a few minutes more once your details are saved.
  • Check one or two insurers direct. Some insurers don't appear on comparison sites at all.
  • Get a quote from your current insurer too. Since January 2022 the FCA's pricing rules mean an insurer can't charge you more to renew than it would charge a new customer for the same cover through the same channel. A rival insurer can still be cheaper, though.

What you'll need to hand

Having these ready makes comparing faster and your quotes more accurate:

  • Your car's registration number (or make, model and trim)
  • Your address and postcode, and where the car is kept overnight
  • Your driving licence details and any points or convictions
  • Your no-claims discount (years) and estimated annual mileage
  • Any named drivers you want on the policy

Answer every question accurately. A wrong mileage, job title or overnight address can void a claim later, and naming a parent as main driver when you drive the car most ("fronting") is insurance fraud.

Make sure the quotes are comparable

The headline price only means something when the policies match. Before you pick the cheapest, check:

  • Total excess: the compulsory plus the voluntary excess. A cheap quote with a high excess can cost more after one claim.
  • Add-ons: breakdown cover, a courtesy car, legal expenses and windscreen cover are included by some insurers and extra with others.
  • No-claims protection, and whether it's included or charged separately.
  • The same start date, drivers and mileage on every quote.
  • Monthly or annual payment: paying monthly is usually a credit agreement and normally costs more over the year than paying up front.

Which level of cover should you compare?

Cover typeWhat it coversBest for
ComprehensiveDamage to your car and others, theft, fire, injuryMost drivers. Often the cheapest, despite the name
Third party, fire & theftOthers' damage + your car for fire/theft onlyOlder, lower-value cars
Third party onlyDamage/injury to others onlyRarely cheapest now. Always compare against comprehensive

Tip: always compare comprehensive too. It is frequently cheaper than third-party cover in the UK. See our cost index and insurance groups guide for what drives your price.

What other drivers pay

The average comprehensive premium people paid was £566 in Q2 2026 (ABI Motor Insurance Premium Tracker, Q2 2026); the average quoted premium was £713 in Q3 2026 (Confused.com Car Insurance Price Index, Q3 2026). A quote is the price offered and a paid premium is the price a customer bought, so the two figures measure different things.

The average hides a wide spread: age, postcode, the car's insurance group and your claims history move the price far more than anything else. Our UK car insurance cost index breaks the figures down by age and region, so you can see where your quotes sit.

Comparing car insurance: FAQs

No. Car Insurance Expert is an independent research site. We don't sell insurance, we don't offer quotes and we don't pass your details to anyone. Use a comparison site or an insurer's own website for quotes, and use our data to judge whether the prices you see are fair.
Yes. Comparison sites don't charge you for a quote. They are paid by the insurer when you buy, and you pay the insurer you choose.
A few weeks before your renewal or start date. Comparison sites' own research has repeatedly found quotes are cheaper when you buy around three to four weeks ahead than in the last few days. Don't let a policy auto-renew without checking the market first.
No. Insurers use a soft search for quotes, which lenders can't see and which doesn't affect your credit score. Paying monthly is a credit agreement, so the insurer may run a fuller check at that point.

Independent & transparent

Car Insurance Expert is an independent UK car-insurance research site. We publish data and guidance. We are not an insurer, broker or comparison service. This site does not make any money: no affiliate links, no advertising, no commission and no sale of leads or your details. See our editorial standards.